Print out chapter

What is an argument?

A strong argument tries to persuade the reader to accept a point of view. When writing an essay, be sure to include the following in your argument:

1. A declarative statement of an idea or opinion.

2. Support for the statement: include relevant facts, opinions based on facts and/or careful reasoning.

When writing an argument, is essential to both make a statement and then provide a foundation of evidence to back up this statement.

What is the Analysis of Argument?

Analysis of Argument questions present a short argument on an issue. You are asked to analyze the argument and discuss how well it is reasoned. You will be looking for flaws in reasoning and weak use of evidence. You will have to consider the assumptions that underlie the writer's thinking and the alternative explanations or counterexamples that might weaken his or her conclusion. It is your job to come up with evidence that would strengthen or refute the argument, or point out the changes that would make it more sound.

	Here is an example of an Analysis of Argument question: Toads cause warts. I touched a toad last week and now I have a wart; therefore the toad was responsible. How would you rate the accuracy of the above statement? Support your position with reasons and examples.

How does the Analysis of Argument differ from the Analysis of Issue?

On Analysis of Issue questions, you are arguing grand issues such as, "Should China be in the WTO," or "Should parents have vouchers to send children to the school of their choice". Reasonable people could differ in their opinions with Analysis of Issue, but no reasonable person would absolutely support something in an Analysis of Argument. When you are working on an Analysis of Argument, look for the fallacies that exist in the reasoning as opposed to inserting your personal opinions on the topic.

Graders expect the following:

• An essay that analyzes several aspects of the argument with critical insight.
  
• A clearly developed and logical essay.
  
• A coherent essay with well-chosen transitions.
  
• An essay that uses varied sentence structure and vocabulary.
  
• An essay free of grammatical errors.

One aspect of argumentation that needs special attention is the use of terms. In an argument, all of the terms should be clear and well-defined. If your terms are unclear, then providing your point will be difficult and will weaken your argument. The emotionally loaded term is such a weak term. Anyone who writes an Analysis of Argument should examine the terms used and be sure to avoid emotive or subjective terms. To the extent possible, define the terms clearly and objectively.

As with Analysis of Issue, the topic sentence of each paragraph must contain the germ of the idea that permeates the entire paragraph. Each example or illustration must connect to that idea using transitional markers such as for example, furthermore, therefore, thus or moreover.

Chapter 3a: Dissecting Arguments